A guide for the locations of all six cats for the side quest “Scavenger Hunt: Big Gay Al’s Big Gay Cats”. If I missed anything or there are any mistakes, let me know!
Note: Images are taken from this page.
Before you start, make sure you have unlocked Timefart Pause from the main quest “Medicinal Fried Fiasco” to get the cats, since they will immediately get scared and hide if you approach them. If you mess up and the cats manage to hide out of your sight, use Timefart Glitch to place them back into their original position.
This quest can be triggered on Day 2, when you head over to Big Gay Al’s House and see him standing outside, smoking a cigarette. Talk to him to start the quest. Another way to start it is to collect one of his cats beforehand.
BEWARE: You get access in this area on Day 3, since at the previous days the road is blocked by a U-Stor-It truck.To get there, you will need to stop the farmer in the Memberberry Farms from blocking your path first. Activate Timefart Pause, then drag the basket to block his path. Once the farmer has been stopped, proceed down the path, where you will see the cat perched on top of a tree. Use Snap N’ Pops to break the branch below the cat to make it fall down. Once the cat has landed onto the ground, activate Timefart Pause, then approach it to pick it up.
BEWARE: You get access in this area on Day 3, since it’s blocked by lava beforehand and you unlock it by passing through it during the main quest “The Hundred Hands of Chaos”.You need to go up there by using Fartkour first, then head to the plank where the cat is located. This cat can be picked up straight away, Timefart Pause is not required to be activated at all.